Loss of HLTF function promotes intestinal carcinogenesis

Background HLTF (Helicase-like Transcription Factor) is a DNA helicase protein homologous to the SWI/SNF family involved in the maintenance of genomic stability and the regulation of gene expression. HLTF has also been found to be frequently inactivated by promoter hypermethylation in human colon cancers. Whether this epigenetic event is required for intestinal carcinogenesis is unknown. Results To address the role of loss of HLTF function in the development of intestinal cancer, we generated Hltf deficient mice. These mutant mice showed normal development, and did not develop intestinal tumors, indicating that loss of Hltf function by itself is insufficient to induce the formation of intestinal cancer. On the Apcmin/+ mutant background, Hltf- deficiency was found to significantly increase the formation of intestinal adenocarcinoma and colon cancers. Cytogenetic analysis of colon tumor cells from Hltf -/-/Apcmin/+ mice revealed a high incidence of gross chromosomal instabilities, including Robertsonian fusions, chromosomal fragments and aneuploidy. None of these genetic alterations were observed in the colon tumor cells derived from Apcmin/+ mice. Increased tumor growth and genomic instability was also demonstrated in HCT116 human colon cancer cells in which HLTF expression was significantly decreased. Conclusion Taken together, our results demonstrate that loss of HLTF function promotes the malignant transformation of intestinal or colonic adenomas to carcinomas by inducing genomic instability. Our findings highly suggest that epigenetic inactivation of HLTF, as found in most human colon cancers, could play an important role in the progression of colon tumors to malignant cancer.


Background
Human colon cancer is the second leading cause of cancer-related death in developed countries. About 50% of the Western population develops adenomatous polyps (a benign colon tumor) by the age of 70, and the lifetime risk for colon cancer is estimated to be 5% [1]. The formation of colon cancer involves a multiple-step process, starting from a small adenomatous polyp and followed by the development of a large adenoma with dysplasia that ultimately leads to the formation of invasive carcinoma (see the recent review by Fearon ER [2]). It is widely accepted that most human colon cancers are initiated by the inactivation of the Adenomatous Polyposis Coli (APC)/Wnt signaling pathway and then progress as the result of a series of mutational activation of oncogenes coupled with the inactivation of tumorsuppressor genes [2,3]. Apart from genetic mutations, epigenetic alterations, particularly aberrant CpG island methylation, have been demonstrated as a major alternative mechanism for suppressing gene function during the development of colon cancer [4][5][6]. To date, many genes that are epigenetically silenced in human colon cancers as well as in colonic adenomas have been identified. However, the function of many of these genes in colon carcinogenesis is still largely unknown. In this study, we have characterized the role of one of these methylated genes, termed Helicase-like Transcription Factor (HLTF), in intestinal carcinogenesis.
Although HLTF was originally identified as a DNAbinding protein that could interact with several gene promoters and enhancers [7][8][9][10][11], recent studies indicate that this DNA helicase is more involved in the DNAdamage repair pathway. First, HLTF has been shown to exhibit an E3 ubiquitin ligase activity for the polyubiquitination of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), which is required for the initiation of an error-free replication through DNA damage lesions [12,13]. Second, HLTF has also been found to display a double-stranded DNA translocase activity, which promotes the resolution of stalled replication forks at DNA damage lesions [14,15]. Third, a recent study indicates that HLTF also possesses a chromatin remodeling activity, which leads to the displacement of DNA-bound proteins on stalled replication forks and facilitates DNA-damage repair [16]. These findings demonstrate that HLTF may be a functional homologue of yeast rad5 and that it plays an important role in an error-free post-replicative repair pathway. The requirement of HLTF for repair of damaged DNA may also implicate a tumor suppression role in human colon cancers, where HLTF has been identified as a common target for methylation and epigenetic gene silencing.
Epigenetic inactivation of HLTF gene expression by promoter hypermethylation has been reported in more than 40% of human colon cancers [17][18][19][20]. The frequency of HLTF promoter methylation was found to increase drastically between early stage of adenomas and advanced adenomas, suggesting that this epigenetic alteration could be a later event in colon carcinogenesis [17,19]. In addition, HLTF methylation was demonstrated to be significantly correlated with poor prognosis in human colon cancer patients [21,22]. Besides colon tumors, HLTF methylation was also commonly detected in human gastric tumors or cancers, but not in other human cancers, such as lung and breast cancers [17,[23][24][25], suggesting that this epigenetic alteration is unique to the tumors of the gastrointestinal tract. However, although HLTF methylation has been demonstrated as a common event in human colon cancer and it has been suggested as a prognostic biomarker [22,26], it is largely unclear whether this epigenetic event is important for the development of this cancer. In the present study, we generated an Hltf deficient mouse allele, and applied this mouse model to characterize the role of loss of HLTF function in the development of intestinal cancer. Our data demonstrates that loss of Hltf has a promoting effect on the transition of intestinal adenomas to invasive cancers, which highly suggests that aberrant HLTF methylation, as found in most human colon cancers, may have an important pathogenetic role in the development of this cancer.

Generation of the Hltf null mouse allele
To study the loss of function of Hltf in vivo, we mutated Hltf in mice by homologous recombination. A gene-targeting vector was generated to replace the exons 1-5 coding for residues 2-208 of Hltf with a nuclear localized LacZ (nls-LacZ) cDNA that was fused in-frame with the endogenous Hltf starting codon ( Figure 1A). Correct homologous recombination in the targeted ES cells was confirmed by Southern blot analysis using both 5' and 3' probes located upstream and downstream of the targeted Hltf sequence ( Figure 1B and 1C). Two independent ES clones were used to produce germlinetransmitting chimeras that were further bred with a ubiquitous Cre transgenic line (EIIa-Cre) to delete the loxP flanked pGK-neo selection marker from the targeted locus ( Figure 1A). The resultant Hltf +/mouse, which was maintained on either a C57BL/6 or C57BL/6/129S1 background, was used to produce Hltf homozygous mutant mice for phenotypic characterization.
To determine whether Hltf expression is completely inactivated in Hltf -/mice, we performed Northern blot analysis of total RNA prepared from control and mutant E10.5 embryos. Whereas Hltf transcripts were identified in control (wild-type and Hltf +/-) embryos using the 5' and 3' Hltf cDNA probes, transcripts were not detected in Hltf -/samples ( Figure 1D). To further demonstrate the absence of Hltf expression in Hltf -/mice, we also applied a more sensitive real time RT-PCR assay to examine the expression of Hltf in derived Hltf -/mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells or mouse embryonic fibroblast (MEF) cells as well as in Hltf -/-E10.5 embryos. With the primer set located on the 3' of Hltf cDNA, a strong amplification of Hltf was detected in the control group, but no signal was found in Hltf -/samples (Figure 1E). These data clearly indicate that the targeted mutation that we introduced into the Hltf mouse genomic locus gave rise to a null allele.

Normal development and lack of intestinal tumors in Hltf null mice
With the established Hltf null allele, we then asked whether loss of Hltf function could affect mouse development and induce the formation of intestinal tumors. As a first approach to address this, we determined the expression pattern of Hltf during development. We took advantage of the inserted nls-LacZ reporter gene in Hltf knockout mice, whose expression is controlled by the endogenous Hltf regulatory elements. Both Hltf +/and Hltf -/mice showed the same LacZ expression pattern. By determining LacZ activity in these mice, we found that Hltf was specifically expressed in the heart at an early developmental stage (E8.5 to E9.5) (Figure 2A).
Hltf exhibited a broader expression pattern at E10.5, with LacZ signals detected in somites, branchial arches, limb bud and brain ( Figure 2B). At later embryonic developmental stages, such as E16.5, Hltf showed wide and strong expression in many tissues, including heart, lung, liver, kidney, spleen and pancreas ( Figure 2C). This wide-spread expression of Hltf was also observed in adult mice (data not shown). In both adult intestine and colon, Hltf expression was mainly detected in the crypts and in the intestinal epithelial cells ( Figure 2D).
This broad expression pattern of Hltf during mouse development might suggest that Hltf is important for development. However, Hltf -/mice were found to have normal embryonic and postnatal development. The Hltf null mice were fertile, and exhibited similar a body weight and life span as their wild-type (wt) littermates. In addition, Hltf -/mice did not display obvious abnormalities of intestinal proliferation or differentiation as determined by the BrdU incorporation assay as well as by the analyses with different intestinal cell lineage markers (Additional file 1 and Additional file 2). To determine whether loss of Hltf function could induce the formation of intestinal tumors, we monitored a cohort of 60 mice fed with a normal diet for a two-year period (30 Hltf -/mice on C57BL/6 background and 30 wt mice matched for age and genetic background). Similar to the wt control group, 10% of Hltf -/mice (3 out of 30) developed liver tumors or lymphomas between 16 Figure 2 Expression of Hltf during mouse development. The analysis was done by determining the activity of LacZ in Hltf knockout mice in which the lacZ reporter was fused in-frame with the endogenous Hltf start codon. (A) Whole mount X-gal staining of E8.5 and E9.5 Hltf +/embryos, demonstrating the specific expression of Hltf in heart (arrows indicate). (B) Whole mount X-gal staining of E10.5 Hltf +/embryos shows broad expression of Hltf. (C) X-gal staining of tissues collected from E16.5 Hltf +/embryos. Hltf was found to be widely expressed in many tissues at this developmental stage. (D) X-gal staining of intestine and colon from two-month old Hltf +/mice. Hltf was identified to be predominately expressed in the crypts as well as in the intestinal epithelial cells in both intestine and colon. and 24 months. However, none of Hltf -/mice formed intestinal tumors or gastric tumors.
Taken together, our results demonstrate that Hltf is dispensable for normal development. Our work also indicates that loss of Hltf function by itself is insufficient to drive the oncogenic process in the gastrointestinal tract, which implicates that the epigenetic inactivation of HLTF, as commonly found in human colon cancers, could be involved in the late stage of intestinal tumor development.

Development of intestinal cancers in Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mutant mice
To determine whether the loss of HLTF function could have a role in the progression of intestinal tumors, we introduced the Hltf null mutation into Apc min/+ mice. The Apc min/+ mice harbor a premature stop codon in one allele of the Apc tumor suppressor gene, and develop multiple intestinal adenomas that mimic human familial adenomatosis polyposis [27]. The adenomas in Apc min/+ mice rarely progress to invasive intestinal or colon cancers [28], making this mouse model an excellent genetic tool for studying the later events involved in intestinal carcinogenesis.
To avoid strain-specific modification of the Apc min/+ intestinal tumor phenotype [29,30], we generated Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice on the C57BL/6 background. Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice became moribund at a similar age as Apc min/+ mice. Post-mortem examination revealed that Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ and Apc min/+ mice developed similar numbers of tumors in the small intestine (average of 65 macroscopic tumors/per mouse in both groups). However, upon histological characterization, most Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice (24 out of 30) were found to form invasive intestinal adenocarcinomas characterized by deeper invasion of tumor cells into the muscularis propria ( Figure 3B and Additional file 3). The invaded neoplastic glandular cells exhibited high β-catenin activity as reflected by the nuclear accumulation of β-catenin detected by immmuno-staining with anti-β-catenin antibody ( Figure 3B). In contrast, most Apc min/+ mice developed only well-defined tubular adenomas or adenomas within the lamina propria ( Figure 3A).
Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice were also found to develop a similar number of neoplastic lesions in the colon as Apc min/+ mice (average of 1.5 macroscopic tumors/per mouse). Histologically, although both Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ and Apc min/+ colon tumors showed tumor growth with a pedunculated morphology protruding into the colonic lumen, the majority of Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ colon tumors displayed a more dramatic glandular atypia that resulted in the formation of numerous mucin-filled cysts ( Figure  4A, B), a characteristic pathological feature for human colon cancers [31]. In addition, most Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ colon tumors were also found to have a strong desmoplastic stromal reaction, suggesting invasion of the lamina propia ( Figure 4B). Furthermore, Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ colon tumors were also found to have stronger and more ubiquitous nuclear-stained β-catenin signals than the tumor cells in Apc min/+ mice ( Figure 4C). These data indicate that colon tumors from Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice had progressed to much higher grades than those from Apc min/+ mice. To further demonstrate the malignancy of colon tumors developed in Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice, we derived cells from these tumors and then subcutaneously injected them into Rag1 -/-/IL2 -/immunodeficient mice. Within 30 days after injection, these cells formed subcutaneous tumors that maintained the morphological and immunohistochemical features of the parental colon tumors ( Figure 4D). This capability of propagating tumor cells into another host, which was not observed with cells derived Apc min/+ colon tumors, further supports that many colon tumors developed in Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice could be malignant cancers.
Collectively, our results demonstrate that loss of Hltf function is able to promote intestinal or colonic carcinogenesis in mice with a mutant Apc background. This finding, together with human epigenetic evidence that HLTF is frequently silenced in the advanced human colon adenomas or cancers but uncommonly in early adenomas [17,19], indicates that epigenetic inactivation of HLTF could be an important event involved in the transition of benign adenomas to malignant colon cancer.

Chromosomal instability in Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ colon tumor cells
Chromosomal instability (CIN) is a genetic hallmark of most human colon cancers, and it has been demonstrated to be important for the progression of colon tumors by increasing the rate of genetic aberration [2,32,33]. Since HLTF has been shown to be required for the maintenance of genomic stability [12][13][14][15][16], it is likely that intestinal or colonic tumors developed in Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice would have increased genomic instability. To examine this, we analyzed metaphase spreads generated from tumor cells (passage 2) derived from colon tumors developed in Apc min/+ and Hltf -/-/Apc min/ + mice. These tumors all showed pronounced cribiform tumor growth without invasive neoplastic glands and were histologically characterized as late stage colonic adenomas.
Consistent with previous findings [34,35], colon tumor cells from Apc min/+ mice showed a near-diploid karyotype and did not harbor obvious chromosomal abnormalities ( Figure 5A). In contrast, three colon tumor cell lines derived from Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mice displayed an aneuploid phenotype ( Figure 5B and 5C). Spectral karytotype (SKY) analysis on these tumor cells further revealed a high incidence of genetic alterations in the forms of nonreciprocal translocations, chromosomal fusions (which include both dicentric chromosomes and centromeric fusions), and chromosomal fragments and breaks ( Figure 5D-G and Table 1). In addition, many chromosomal fusions in Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ colon tumor cells were found to lack telomere signals ( Figure 5I), indicating the presence of telomere dysfunction in these tumor cells. Collectively, these results demonstrate that Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ colon tumors had gross chromosomal abnormalities, similar to the CIN phenotype as described in most human colorectal cancers.

Increased tumor growth and chromosomal instability in HCT116 human colon cancer cells with HLTF knockdown
To determine whether loss of HLTF function would also lead to a similar tumor-promoting effect in human colon cancer as we demonstrated in the Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mouse model, we applied a lentiviral based shRNA knockdown approach to down-regulate HLTF expression in HCT116 human colon cancer cells. HCT116 cells are one of a few colon cancer cell lines that lack HLTF promoter methylation [17], and express high levels of HLTF ( Figure 6A). In addition, these cells are near-diploid with a stable karyotype [36], which would also allow us to determine whether loss of HLTF function in human colon cancer cells could induce chromosomal abnormalities in a manner similar to the Hltfdeficient mouse colon tumor cells.
As shown in Figure 6B, HLTF expression was significantly reduced to almost undetectable protein level in the transduced HCT116 cells that were stably integrated with HLTF shRNAs (HCT116 HLTFshRNA1 and     tumor size as compared with that of the scramble control ( Figure 6C). Moreover, both HCT116 HLTFshRNA1 and HCT116 HLTFshRNA2 subcutaneous tumors also frequently exhibited the invasion of tumor cells into the subcutaneous muscle layer that was uncommonly observed in the control tumors ( Figure 6D). To confirm that HLTF expression was indeed down-regulated in these tumors, we performed immunohistochemistry with an anti-HLTF antibody. Both HCT116 HLTFshRNA1 and HCT116 HLTFshRNA2 subcutaneous tumors showed significantly lower expression of HLTF as compared to the scramble control tumors ( Figure 6D). Taken together, our data indicate that down-regulation of HLTF in human colon cancer cells may promote tumor growth and malignancy, similar to what we found in the Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ mouse model. We then performed cytogenetic analysis to determine whether down-regulation of HLTF expression in human colon cancer cells induced chromosomal abnormalities. Detailed SKY analysis of metaphase spreads from both short term (10 days) cultured HCT116 parental cells and HCT116 scramble cells revealed the presence of neardiploid chromosomes with a few highly conserved chromosomal translocations ( Figure 7A), consistent with the documented karyotype for HCT116 parental cells [37]. This near-diploid karyotype was also observed in the second generation of HCT116 cells and HCT116 scramble cells that were derived from the subcutaneous tumors formed by these cells (Figure 7C), further indicating that HCT116 cells have a stable chromosome karyotype as demonstrated previously [38,39]. In contrast, both shortterm cultured and the second generation of HCT116 HLTFshRNA1 and HCT116 HLTFshRNA2 tumor cells exhibited significantly increased chromosomal abnormalities in the forms of chromosomal loss and chromosomal fusions and breaks as compared to the control groups (p < 0.001) ( Figure 7B-C). In addition, approximately 15% of metaphases from HCT116 HLTFshRNA1 and HCT116 HLTFshRNA2 tumor cells showed high numbers of trisomy ( Figure 7D). These results clearly indicate that down-regulation of HLTF in human colon cancer cells is able to induce chromosomal abnormalities.

Discussion
There is now strong evidence that a series of genetic alterations are required for the pathogenesis of human colon cancer. Specific gene mutations, such as in the APC gene, initiate the formation of colonic adenomas and others (e.g. TP53 mutations as well as other alterations, including KRAS activation) drive the malignant transformation of the adenomas in a multistep progression model [2,3]. More recently, epigenetic alterations, specifically aberrant DNA methylation, have been found to occur commonly in colon cancers [4,5]. Although there is controversy regarding the significance of these alterations in the pathogenesis of colon cancer, more and more data indicate that the aberrant methylation of at least some of these genes, such as MLH1 (MutL homolog 1), MGMT (O-6-methylguanine-DNA methytransferase) and HIC1 (hypermethylated in cancer 1) can be pathogenetic in colorectal carcinogenesis [2,6]. Here, we have added another example to demonstrate the importance of epigenetic alterations in this carcinogenesis.
In this study, we focused on determining the role of loss of HLTF function in the development of colon cancer. The HLTF promoter has been found to be hypermethylated in more than 40% of human colon cancers [17][18][19][20], suggesting that HLTF is a common target for methylation in this cancer. All colon cancer cells that lacked HLTF expression had the methylation of CpG islands within the HLTF promoter, while methylation was not detected in the HLTF-expressing cells [17] (Figure 6A), further indicating that this epigenetic event leads to a complete inactivation of HLTF expression in colon cancer cells. To determine the role of loss of HLTF function, in this study, we generated Hltf deficient mice (Figure 1). Although these mice did not develop intestinal or colonic tumors, the majority of them were found to develop invasive intestinal and colonic cancers upon Apc mutation-mediated tumor initiation ( Figures  4 and 5). Our results strongly suggest that aberrant methylation of HLTF, which leads to the loss of this gene's function as found in most human colon cancers, could have a pathogenetic role rather than being a consequence of colorectal carcinogenesis. This epigenetic event could be important for driving the transition of benign adenomas to the malignant adenocarcinomas, which is consistent with human tumor data showing that HLTF promoter methylation is mainly detected in the advanced colonic adenomas and cancers, but not in the early stage of adenomatous polyp [17,19]. The high frequency of HLTF promoter hypermethylation observed in these tumors indicates that the silencing of this gene could confer a selective advantage for the progression of these tumors to the malignant cancers.
Although the mechanism by which loss of HLTF function results in this malignant transformation still needs to be defined, our data demonstrating gross chromosomal abnormalities in Hltf deficient colon tumor cells may suggest that genomic instability induced in these tumors is a driving force for this carcinogenesis. Genomic instability is a characteristic of human colon cancers, and has been implicated in the initiation and progression of these cancers by increasing the rate of genetic alterations [2]. Two types of genetic instability have been found in human colon cancer: microsatellite instability (MIN) and chromosomal instability (CIN). Tumors with MIN display normal diploid with no obvious chromosomal defects but have high incidence of instability in microsatellite repeats linked to impaired mismatch repair (MMR) [40]. The predominant mechanism identified to inactivate MMR in these tumors is epigenetic silencing through promoter methylation [41], although somatic mutations in MMR genes also occur [42]. CIN, which accounts for 85% of colorectal cancers, exhibits aneuploid, allelic losses and other chromosomal abnormalities, such as translocation, fusion and breaks [32]. Colon cancers with CIN phenotype have been found to behave more aggressively in terms of invasiveness and metastasis [32]. Although its molecular basis remains largely elusive, CIN is thought to arise from structural defects involving centromere or centrosome, microtubule dysfunction, telomere defects, chromosomal fragility and cell cycle checkpoint failure [2,6]. In this work, we have provided solid evidence that Hltf deficient mouse colon tumors display severe chromosomal abnormalities, similar to CIN as described in human colon cancers ( Figure 5). We have also demonstrated that down-regulation of HLTF increased chromosomal abnormalities in human colon cancer cells (Figure 7). Furthermore, similar to human colon cancers with a CIN phenotype, we have also found that Hltf deficient mouse colon tumors or HLTF knockdown human colon cancer cells developed more malignant features, such as invasiveness, as compared to the tumor cells that contain functional HLTF (Figures 4, 5 and 6). All these findings indicate that the genomic instability induced in HLTF deficient colon tumors likely plays an important role in the malignant transformation of these tumors. Future studies using our established Hltf knockout mouse colon tumor model to identify the genetic mutations involved in this pathogenesis have the potential to provide a deeper understanding of colon cancer development.
The presence of a CIN phenotype in Hltf knockout or knockdown tumor cells also implicates loss of HLTF function as an additional mechanism to induce CIN phenotypes in human colon cancer. The involvement of HLTF in the post-replicative DNA damage-repair pathway has been demonstrated by several recent studies [12][13][14][15][16]. In these work, HLTF was shown to display a similar function as yeast rad5 in the polyubiquitination of PCNA, which is required for initiating an error-free post-replicative repair activity [12,13]. HLTF was also found to have both DNA translocase and chromatin remodeling activities to facilitate the repair of damaged DNA on stalled replication forks [14][15][16]. Therefore, HLTF could be an important factor in the post-replicative repair pathway. Without HLTF, it is likely that the progression of the replication fork would be blocked at DNA damage lesions, resulting in an accumulation of DNA intermediates that trigger recombination and genomic instability [43]. Our cytogenetic data demonstrating the gross chromosomal abnormalities present in Hltf deficient mouse tumor or in HLTF knockdown HCT116 colon cancer cells strongly support this notion. Our data also agree with many other studies indicating that aberrant post-replicative repair activity is a major source of the mutations and chromosome rearrangements that could be important for tumorigenesis. Interestingly, mice deficient in Hltf alone were found to develop normally and did not display any pathological disorders associated with genetic instability. This may due to the robust replication checkpoints present in normal mouse cells, which, upon DNA damage, could boost a DNA damage response that arrests cells that harbor unrepaired DNA damage [44]. These unrepaired cells could undergo apoptosis and then be replenished by cells differentiated from a pool of progenitor and stem cells during development. However, when these checkpoint pathways are not functional, the cells that contain defective or unrepaired DNA lesions could still progress through the cell cycle, resulting in broken chromosomes, genome aberrations and an accumulation of mutations [44,45]. A recent study indicates that APC could play an important role in the DNA replication checkpoints by stabilizing the association of DNA replication complexes at stalled DNA replication forks [46]. Consistent with this finding, tumor cells that have lost APC function, such as human SW480 colon cancer cells, have been found to lose the capacity to arrest cells with damaged DNA [46]. Therefore, Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ colon tumor cells may have impaired replication checkpoints, which could facilitate cell cycle progression to enhance the genomic instability in these tumor cells.
HLTF has also been demonstrated to interact with several different gene promoters and enhancers [7][8][9][10][11], suggesting its potential role in the regulation of gene expression. We recently performed micoarray-based gene expression analyses and did not find significant changes of gene expression between Hltf +/+ and Hltf -/mouse ES cells or in HCT116 cells with and without HLTF knockdown. In both cases, a very few genes showed 2-fold change with the statistical significance (Additional file 4). None of these genes have been implicated in tumorigenesis or in the maintenance of genomic stability. Therefore, the loss of HLTF function is unlikely to mis-regulate the expression of specific genes, leading to the development of colon cancers.

Conclusions
We have provided direct genetic evidence that loss of HLTF function promotes the malignant transformation of intestinal or colonic adenomas to carcinomas. We have also demonstrated that this pathogenetic outcome could be associated with the role of HLTF in the maintenance of genomic stability. Given the high frequency of epigenetic inactivation by hypermethylation of HLTF in human colon cancers, our studies strongly suggest that this epigenetic alteration could be directly involved in the development of colon cancer rather than a consequence of this carcinogenesis.

Construction of Hltf gene-targeting vector
The Hltf gene-targeting vector was generated based on a PCR-based cloning strategy [47]. Briefly, the mouse Hltf genomic fragments required for the 5' and 3' arms of homology were PCR-amplified from the genomic DNA of R1 ES cells (on 129S1 background) with a high-fidelity polymerase (TaKaRa). The primer sequences are listed in Additional file 5. After validation by DNA sequencing, the Hltf 5'arm DNA fragment was ligated upstream of a nlsLacZpA-loxP-pGKneo-loxP cassette. This vector was further inserted by a DNA fragment containing Hltf 3'arm and pGK-DTA cassette to generate the final gene-targeting vector that contains Hltf 5'arm-nlsLacZpA-loxP-pGKneo-loxP-Hltf 3'arm-pGK-DTA ( Figure 1A).

Generation of Hltf deficient mice
The Hltf gene-targeting vector was linearized with SacII and then electroporated into R1 ES cells. The transfected ES cells were selected with G418 (250 μg/ml), and G418-resistant ES clones were screened by Southern blot analysis for the correctly targeted allele using BamHI (for the 5' external probe) and EcoRI (for the 3' external probe) digestions. Both the 5' and 3' external probes were PCR amplified with primers listed in Additional file 5. Two independently targeted ES cell clones were used to generate chimeric mice by ES cell⇔diploid embryo aggregation. Transmitting chimeric males were crossed with an EIIa-Cre line (Jackson laboratories, Bar Harbor, Maine) to delete the loxP flanked neo cassette from the targeted allele. The resultant mouse allele was further bred with 129S1 females to produce hemizygous transgenic offspring on 129S1/C57BL/6 background. Hltf +/mice were also backcrossed to C57BL/6 for eight generations. All mouse experiments were performed in accordance with procedures approved by the University of Manitoba Animal Care and Use Committee.

Mouse intestinal and colonic tumor analysis on Hltf/Apc mutant mice
The Apc Min/+ mice were purchased from The Jackson Laboratory and maintained on a C57/B6 genetic background. These mice were bred with Hltf +/-(C57/B6 background) to generate a cohort of Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ , Apc min/+ and Hltf +/-/Apc min/+ mice for intestinal tumor analysis. Mice were sacrificed by cervical dislocation, and the entire small intestine and colon were flushed with cold PBS and dissected longitudinally. The number, location and size of tumors in the intestine or colon were examined and recorded. Small intestinal and colonic tumors were further histologically analyzed by hemtoxylin/eosin staining and immunohistochemistry.
Establishment of colon tumor cells from Hltf/Apc mutant mice and growth in Rag1 -/-/IL2 -/immunocompromised mice Tumor cells from Hltf -/-/Apc min/+ and Apc min/+ colon tumors were generated as described [35]. The cells were grown in 6 cm culture dishes plated with mitomycintreated mouse embryonic fibroblast (MEF) cells using the culture conditions as described [35]. The early passage (p2) cells were collected either for tumorigenicity analysis by injecting 10 5 cells subcutaneously to Rag1 -/-/ IL2 -/mice (purchased from Jackson Laboratory), or for cytogenetic characterization.

Lentiviral based shRNA knockdown of HLTF expression in HCT116 cells
Lentiviral vectors expressing shRNA against human HLTF (NM 003071, V2LHS 254799, _153142, _153143, _153144, _153146) or scrambled control were obtained from the GIPZ lentiviral shRNAmir library (Open Biosystems, Thermo Scientifc) acquired at the University of Manitoba. The pGIPZ lentiviral vector expresses a short hairpin RNA modeled by human microRNA-30 (miR30) primary transcript for increased Drosha and Dicer processing. TurboGFP reporter gene and puromycin drug resistance marker are expressed as part of a bicistronic transcript. Preparation and infection of lentiviral particles into HCT116 cells (from ATCC) were performed based on an established procedure as described previously [49]. After infection, HCT116 cells were treated with 0.75 μg/ ml puromycin for four days. The puromycin-resistant clones were pooled to determine HLTF expression by Western blot analysis with anti-HLTF antibody (Sigma). 10 5 cells from these established stable cell lines were subcutaneously injected to Rag1 -/-/IL2 -/mice to determine the effect of HLTF knockdown on tumor growth. These cells, as well as cells derived from subcutaneous tumors, were also utilized for cytogenetic analysis.

Cytogenetic analysis
Metaphase spreads for SKY analysis were performed using the SKT kit (ASI) according to the manufacturer's instructions and previously published methods [50]. In each cell line, at least 20 metaphase spreads were studied. Q-FISH analysis was performed as previously described [51].

Northern blot analysis
Total RNA from freshly dissected mouse E10.5 embryos was extracted using TRIzol (Life Technologies, Inc.). 20 μg of total RNA was separated on a 1% agarose-formaldehyde gel and transferred to Hybond nylon membrane (Amersham). Hybridization was carried out in Per-fectHyb (Sigma) with 1.5 × 10 6 cpm/ml of 5' and 3' Hltf cDNA probes. Both 5' and 3' cDNA probes were PCRamplified with the primers listed in Additional file 5.

Western blot analysis
For Western blots, cells were lysed in RIPA buffer. 30 μg lysate was separated by 8% SDS-PAGE and transferred to nitrocellulose membrane, which was blocked with 5% non-fat milk and incubated with rabbit anti-HLTF antibody (Sigma, dilution 1:500) at 4°overnight. Protein was detected using an enhanced chemiluminescence system (Amersham Life Science).

Statistical analysis
A paired t-test (two tailed) was used to analyze the statistical significance of chromosomal abnormalities in tumor cells. P < 0.05 was considered indicative of statistical significance.

Additional material
Additional file 1: Loss of Hltf function does not affect the cellular proliferation in small intestine and colon. The small intestines and colons collected from 2-month old Hltf +/+ and Hltf -/mice were stained with Haematoxylin-eosin and anti-Brdu antibody. Both Hltf +/+ and Hltf -/intestine and colon displayed normal morphology and a similar number of BrdU positive cells within the crypt (2 h after BrdU injection) and in crypt-villus axis (24 h after BrdU injection).
Additional file 2: Loss of Hltf function does not affect the differentiation of epithelial cells in small intestine and colon. The small intestines and colons from 2-month old Hltf +/+ and Hltf -/mice were analyzed using several intestinal cell-lineage markers. The Goblet cells were determined by staining with Alcian blue and periodic acid-Schiff (PAS). The enteroendocrine cells were analyzed by immunostaining with anti-chromogranin A, and the Paneth cells in small intestine were detected by anti-lysozyme antibody. Both Hltf +/+ and Hltf -/intestines or colons showed very similar staining patterns for these markers.
Additional file 4: List of genes that showed expression changes between Hltf +/+ and Hltf -/mouse ES cells and in HCT116 cells with and without HLTF knockdown. The microarray expression assays were carried out by the Center for Applied Genomics at the Toronto Hospital for Sick Children. Three independent cell lines from each group were analyzed. The changes with the statistical significance (p < 0.05) are highlighted by yellow. Red indicates the change of gene expression cannot be validated by real-time PCR.
Additional file 5: List of PCR primers that were applied in this study.