Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of mean methylation between normal and tumor samples for the 17 genes studied with respect to the various clinicopathological parameters

From: Investigation of DNA damage response and apoptotic gene methylation pattern in sporadic breast tumors using high throughput quantitative DNA methylation analysis technology

CLINICOPATHOLOGICAL PARAMETERS

TRAIL

DR4

DR5

DCR1

DCR2

CASP8

FLIP

BCL2

CYCS

ER+ (N = 27)

13a, 14b, 0c

11, 15, 1

8, 16, 3

6, 21, 0

6, 20, 1

12, 15, 0

14, 11, 2

18, 9, 0

14, 13, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

48a, 52b, 0c

41, 56, 4

30, 59, 11

22, 78, 0

22, 74, 4

44, 56, 0

52, 41, 7

67, 33, 0

52, 48, 0

P a

0.857

0.741

0.137

0.007

0.004

0.791

0.115

0.095

0.81

P b

0.911

1.050

0.388

0.060

0.068

0.961

0.391

0.404

0.918

ER- (N = 30)

11, 14, 5

23, 7, 0

10, 20, 0

12, 18, 0

4, 26, 0

10, 18, 2

17, 13, 0

10, 20, 0

11, 19, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

37, 47, 17

77, 23, 0

33, 67, 0

40, 60, 0

13, 87, 0

33, 60, 7

57, 43, 0

33, 67, 0

37, 63, 0

P a

0.228

0.001

0.010

0.013

0.00007

0.057

0.41

0.026

0.053

P b

0.298

0.009

0.057

0.055

0.001

0.108

0.498

0.074

0.113

PR+ (N = 24)

11, 13, 0

8, 15, 1

7, 16, 1

6, 18, 0

6, 18, 0

11, 13, 0

13, 9, 2

16, 8, 0

11, 13, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

46, 54, 0

33, 63, 4

29, 67, 4

25, 75, 0

25, 75, 0

46, 54, 0

54, 38, 8

67, 33, 0

46, 54, 0

P a

0.989

0.196

0.063

0.015

0.001

0.977

0.123

0.157

0.310

P b

0.989

0.370

0.268

0.128

0.017

1.038

0.418

0.445

0.479

PR- (N = 33)

13, 15, 5

26, 7, 0

11, 20, 2

12, 21, 0

4, 28, 1

11, 20, 2

18, 15, 0

12, 21, 0

14, 19, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

39, 45, 15

79, 21, 0

33, 61, 6

36, 64, 0

12, 85, 3

33, 61, 6

55, 45, 0

36, 64, 0

42, 58, 0

P a

0.36

0.0002

0.019

0.004

0.00003

0.082

0.325

0.098

0.180

P b

0.437

0.002

0.081

0.023

0.001

0.232

0.425

0.238

0.306

NODE- (N = 40)

19, 20, 1

20, 18, 2

11, 27, 2

15, 25, 0

6, 33, 1

18, 21, 1

25, 14, 1

20, 19, 1

15, 25, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

48, 50, 3

50, 45, 5

28, 68, 5

38, 63, 0

15, 83, 3

45, 53, 3

63, 35, 3

50, 48, 3

36, 63, 0

P a

0.828

0.162

0.011

0.003

0.00001

0.267

0.107

0.581

0.021

P b

0.828

0.275

0.062

0.026

0.0002

0.378

0.202

0.658

0.071

NODE+ (N = 41)

21, 16, 4

27, 14, 0

14, 25, 2

14, 27, 0

10, 30, 1

13, 26, 2

20, 19, 2

21, 20, 0

18, 23, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

51, 39, 10

66, 34, 0

34, 61, 5

34, 66, 05

24, 73, 2

32, 63, 5

49, 46, 5

51, 49, 0

44, 56, 0

P a

0.276

0.017

0.039

0.001

0.00001

0.032

0.165

0.564

0.496

P b

0.469

0.072

0.095

0.006

0.0002

0.091

0.312

0.685

0.703

T1 + T2 (N = 59)

33, 23, 3

34, 23, 2

16, 40, 3

22, 37, 0

11, 47, 1

23, 34, 4

36, 20, 3

33, 26, 0

27, 32, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

56, 39, 5

58, 39, 3

27, 68, 5

37, 63, 0

19, 80, 2

39, 58, 3

61, 34, 5

56, 44, 0

46, 54, 0

P a

0.185

0.011

0.002

0.001

0.0000001

0.068

0.007

0.213

0.077

P b

0.262

0.037

0.011

0.009

0.000002

0.116

0.030

0.279

0.119

T3+T4 (N = 22)

7, 13, 2

13, 9, 0

9, 12, 1

7, 15, 0

5, 16, 1

8, 13, 1

9, 13, 0

8, 13, 1

6, 16, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

32, 59, 9

59, 41, 0

41, 55, 5

32, 68, 0

23, 73, 5

36, 59, 5

41, 59, 0

36, 59, 5

27, 73, 0

P a

0.321

0.495

0.204

0.002

0.001

0.217

0.884

0.073

0.194

P b

0.496

0.647

0.495

0.017

0.017

0.461

0.884

0.310

0.550

STAGE 1+2 (N = 51)

25, 23, 3

27, 22, 2

15, 34, 2

20, 31, 0

9, 42, 0

21, 28, 2

31, 18, 2

28, 23, 0

22, 29, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

49, 45, 6

53, 43, 4

29, 67, 4

39, 61, 0

18, 82, 0

41, 55, 4

61, 35, 4

55, 45, 0

43, 57, 0

P a

0.692

0.032

0.011

0.003

0.000001

0.118

0.035

0.436

0.074

P b

0.692

0.078

0.062

0.026

0.00001

0.182

0.074

0.570

0.140

STAGE 3+4 (N = 30)

15, 13, 2

20, 10, 0

10, 18, 2

9, 21, 0

7, 21, 2

10, 19, 1

14, 15, 1

13, 16, 1

11, 19, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

50, 43, 7

67, 33, 0

33, 60, 7

30, 70, 0

23, 70, 7

33, 63, 3

47, 50, 3

43, 53, 3

37, 63, 0

P a

0.576

0.181

0.041

0.001

0.0002

0.100

0.347

0.279

0.217

P b

0.653

0.513

0.174

0.009

0.003

0.340

0.492

0.527

0.527

GRADE 1+2 (N = 32)

11, 19, 2

13, 18, 1

11, 20, 1

10, 22, 0

7, 25, 0

15, 17, 0

17, 13, 2

14, 18, 0

15, 17, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

34, 59, 6

41, 56, 3

34, 63, 35

31, 69, 0

22, 78, 0

47, 53, 0

53, 41, 6

44, 56, 0

47, 53, 0

P a

0.085

0.681

0.088

0.009

0.0002

0.793

0.153

0.575

0.278

P b

0.361

0.827

0.299

0.077

0.003

0.899

0.434

0.815

0.675

GRADE 3 (N = 25)

13, 9, 3

21, 4, 0

7, 16, 2

8, 17, 0

3, 21, 1

7, 16, 2

14, 11, 0

14, 11, 0

10, 15, 0

PERCENTAGE (%)

52, 36, 12

84, 16, 0

28, 64, 8

32, 68, 0

12, 84, 4

28, 64, 8

56, 44, 0

56, 44, 0

40, 60, 0

P a

0.353

0.0003

0.006

0.007

0.0001

0.100

0.313

0.893

0.187

P b

0.500

0.003

0.034

0.030

0.002

0.283

0.484

0.893

0.318

CLINICOPATHOLOGICAL PARAMETERS

ATM

TP53

BRCA1

BRCA2

CHEK2

TIP60

RNF8

H2AX

 

ER+ (N = 27)

16, 11, 0

14, 10, 3

10, 17, 0

9, 14, 4

13, 10, 4

12, 14, 1

18, 9, 0

13, 11, 3

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

59, 41, 0

52, 37, 11

37, 63, 0

33, 52, 15

48, 37, 15

44, 52, 4

67, 33, 0

48, 41, 11

 

P a

0.264

0.390

0.374

0.260

0.988

0.760

0.062

0.474

 

P b

0.561

0.663

0.706

0.631

0.988

0.994

0.351

0.733

 

ER- (N = 30)

12, 15, 3

8, 21, 1

14, 16, 0

7, 21, 2

14, 16, 0

16, 8, 6

17, 11, 2

11, 18, 1

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

40, 50, 10

27, 70, 3

47, 53, 0

23, 70, 7

47, 53, 0

53, 27, 20

57, 37, 7

37, 60, 3

 

P a

0.857

0.039

0.765

0.016

0.885

0.111

0.206

0.150

 

P b

0.911

0.095

0.867

0.054

0.885

0.189

0.292

0.232

 

PR+ (N = 24)

13, 11, 0

12, 9, 3

7, 17, 0

8, 13, 3

12, 10, 2

10, 12, 2

17, 7, 0

13, 9, 2

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

54, 46, 0

50, 38, 13

29, 71, 0

33, 54, 13

50, 42, 8

42, 50, 8

71, 29, 0

54, 38, 8

 

P a

0.658

0.519

0.174

0.192

0.974

0.858

0.039

0.298

 

P b

0.860

0.735

0.423

0.408

1.104

1.042

0.221

0.507

 

PR- (N = 33)

15, 15, 3

10, 22, 1

17, 16, 0

8, 22, 3

15, 16, 2

18, 10, 5

18, 13, 2

11, 20, 2

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

45, 45, 9

30, 67, 3

52, 48, 0

24, 67, 9

45, 48, 6

55, 30, 15

55, 39, 6

33, 61, 6

 

P a

0.53

0.120

0.907

0.023

0.814

0.230

0.243

0.141

 

P b

0.601

0.255

0.907

0.078

0.865

0.355

0.344

0.266

 

NODE- (N = 40)

22, 15, 3

13, 25, 2

14, 26, 0

14, 22, 4

18, 20, 2

14, 22, 4

22, 17, 1

13, 25, 2

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

55, 38, 8

33, 63, 5

35, 65, 0

35, 55, 10

45, 50, 5

35, 55, 10

55, 43, 3

33, 63, 5

 

P a

0.068

0.028

0.080

0.370

0.591

0.183

0.291

0.021

 

P b

0.165

0.079

0.170

0.449

0.628

0.283

0.381

0.089

 

NODE+ (N = 41)

21, 19, 1

19, 20, 2

20, 21, 0

10, 26, 5

17, 19, 5

27, 11, 3

24, 16, 1

17, 21, 3

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

51, 46, 2

46, 49, 5

49, 51

24, 63, 12

41, 46, 12

66, 27, 7

59, 39, 2

41, 51, 7

 

P a

0.973

0.553

0.979

0.001

0.465

0.031

0.120

0.942

 

P b

1.034

0.723

0.979

0.009

0.719

0.105

0.255

1.068

 

T1 + T2 (N = 59)

35, 21, 3

23, 33, 3

26, 33, 0

19, 36, 4

27, 28, 4

32, 24, 3

35, 23, 1

19, 37, 3

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

59, 36, 5

39, 56, 5

44, 56, 0

32, 61, 7

46, 47, 7

54, 41, 5

59, 39, 2

32, 63, 5

 

P a

0.013

0.407

0.694

0.056

0.639

0.276

0.037

0.040

 

P b

0.037

0.461

0.694

0.106

0.679

0.335

0.090

0.085

 

T3+T4 (N = 22)

8, 13, 1

9, 12, 1

8, 14, 0

5, 12, 5

8, 11, 3

9, 9, 4

11. 10, 1

11, 9, 2

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

36, 59, 1

41, 55, 5

36, 64, 0

23, 55, 23

36, 50, 14

41, 41, 18

50, 45, 5

50, 41, 9

 

P a

0.230

0.433

0.157

0.035

0.295

0.744

0.767

0.562

 

P b

0.434

0.613

0.534

0.198

0.502

0.843

0.815

0.682

 

STAGE 1+2 (N = 51)

31, 17, 3

20, 27, 4

21, 30, 0

18, 31, 2

23, 25, 3

25, 23, 3

32, 18, 1

17, 32, 2

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

61, 33, 6

39, 53, 8

41, 59, 0

35, 61, 4

45, 49, 6

49, 45, 6

63, 35, 2

33, 63, 4

 

P a

0.013

0.397

0.499

0.100

0.674

0.636

0.015

0.020

 

P b

0.055

0.562

0.606

0.170

0.716

0.721

0.051

0.057

 

STAGE 3+4 (N = 30)

12, 17, 1

12, 18, 0

13, 17, 0

6, 17, 7

12, 14, 4

16, 10, 4

14, 15, 1

13, 14, 3

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

40, 57, 3

40, 60, 0

43, 57, 0

20, 57, 23

40, 47, 13

53, 33, 13

47, 50, 3

43, 47, 10

 

P a

0.252

0.434

0.280

0.005

0.303

0.524

0.983

0.674

 

P b

0.536

0.568

0.476

0.028

0.468

0.636

0.983

0.716

 

GRADE 1+2 (N = 32)

13, 17, 2

14, 17, 1

11, 21, 0

9, 19, 4

13, 17, 2

14, 14, 4

17, 13, 2

16, 13, 3

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

41, 53, 6

44, 53, 3

34, 66, 0

28, 59, 13

41, 53, 6

44, 44, 13

53, 41, 6

50, 41, 9

 

P a

0.845

0.486

0.64

0.043

0.491

0.452

0.487

0.795

 

P b

0.845

0.918

0.837

0.244

0.759

0.961

0.828

0.845

 

GRADE 3 (N = 25)

15, 9, 1

8, 14, 3

13, 12, 0

7, 16, 2

14, 9, 2

14, 8, 3

18, 7, 0

8, 16,1

 

PERCENTAGE (%)

60, 36, 4

32, 56, 12

52, 48, 0

28, 64, 8

16, 76, 8

56, 32, 12

72, 28, 0

32, 64, 4

 

P a

0.141

0.494

0.686

0.114

0.523

0.648

0.010

0.121

 

P b

0.266

0.646

0.729

0.277

0.635

0.734

0.034

0.257

 
  1. Pa value for Wilcoxon signed-rank test between breast tumor and adjacent normal tissue. Pb value for Wilcoxon signed-rank test between breast tumor and adjacent normal tissue after Benjamini Hochberg correction - significant values shown in bold. a: Number and corresponding percentage of hypomethylated tumors compared to adjacent normal, b: Number and corresponding percentage of hypermethylated tumors compared to adjacent normal, c: Number and corresponding percentage of tumors that show same methylation compared to adjacent normal.